“The issue, in other words, isn’t that [name] has [done heinous act], but that [pronoun] can.”
There’s a very interesting article by David L. Ulin that includes this statement. Of course, he’s got the blanks filled in, and with the blanks filled in, it gives one the feeling that maybe [name] should be stopped or regulated. And in his article, Mr. Ulin has many good points. But I always like to pull out my names and see the statement as it applies to the world in general, not just one entity that I may or may not be in favor of.
The problem is not that you have done something wrong, but that you have the power to.
And I find that thought disturbing. He goes on to say, “We are asked to trust each other’s goodwill…” like that’s a disaster waiting to happen. And maybe it is. Maybe people will wield the power they have in terrible, terrible ways. Certainly when it’s a big corporation like he’s referring to in the article (ah… suddenly he sounds less crazy, right?) we have seen too many examples of just that.
But we cannot run a country – certainly not our lives – on the concept that we must shut down the evil that everyone is capable of. Because in doing so, we also shut down the good. I do not believe that power automatically corrupts. For every Hitler we have a Mother Teresa, for every Osama bin Laden, a Mike Kim. I know the temptation to prevent the possibility of evil is well-meant and, for some people, even holy. But you can strip the rights and resources of every man and woman on the planet in a pre-emptive strike, and all you will have is hopeless, helpless masses who are still not safe. Evil will find a way.
Now I’m not saying that when bad things happen – when they actually happen – we shouldn’t do our damnedest to stop evil as it marches forward and to help others who’ve been hurt in it’s path. I’m not saying we should leave our doors unlocked at night and walk down the most desloate and dangerous streets in our hometowns at midnight. But we have to accept the fact that we are, in fact, not asked but required to trust each other’s goodwill every single day of our lives. That is the definition of society. We have got to quit saying “Watch out, or people will screw you over” – that puts the responsibility on the wrong person. We have to start saying, “Be an ethical human being. Less is just not acceptable.”
My faith has one law: “If it harms none, do as you will.” Look at the ramifications of your actions for yourself and others before you act. If you can’t see how it hurts somebody, though, it’s your right as a human being. Having political, social, or financial power is no more evil than being smart or strong or fast. Using what you have to hurt or usurp the rights of others is. Power is a tricky thing, it can be a scary thing, but it is a necessary thing. If we can quit fear-mongering and focus on teaching the wise and ethical use of power, then we’re going to see a saner, safer, stronger world.